I have used all three of these. I first bought the Elfa (Container Store) for one bedroom. It was extremely expensive. Spent 5 times more than the others for something very simple. Everything is cut for you once you have the measurements. It is very sturdy and very well made, of course. It is probably over kill for a closet organizer. They have a lot of nice accessories for it and can be dressed up to look nicer than the others. Biggest negative which really surprises me since Closetmaid and Rubbermaid doesn't have this problem is you can't slide a hanger all the way across.
My next project was using Rubbermaid. I liked the idea it was adjustable. It was very easy to install. I bought the delux 8 feet kit. One problem is you will sometimes have left over parts and in my case I also had to buy one extra part since the way I wanted it was a little different that what options you had with their kit. After installing it I found I just didn't need to change it, so the adjustability probaly was not a plus for me but some people may want to make changes after using it for awhile. Biggest negative which really isn't a negative is that it is flimsy compared to the Elfa which is like a tank. That is because it is adjustable but it is sturdy enough. I have no problems with that. Another possible negative is it only comes with 12 inch shelves for closets. If you really need something bigger you can go into their garage sections which has 16 inches shelves.
My last project was Closetmaid. I used Closetmaid for my wife's closet since she wanted 16 inch shelves and I didn't feel it needed to be adjustable. Now if you don't want to be doing your own cutting which can be a chore without the right tools then go with Rubbermaid. But I have the right tools so cutting was not a problem. I bought mine at Lowe's. If you have all your measurements you can do the cutting their. They have a bolt cutter that cuts right through it. I did all my cutting at home since I have bolt cutters and metal saws. I like Closetmaid since it was sturdier than Rubbermaid and I just buy what I need. It also has a nice selection of accessories from wire drawers to shoe organizers. What I really liked is their clothes hamper. It pulls out on a slide then pushes in after you throw your dirty clothes in.
Now the surprise is the vertical hangers for all three companies all have the same slot design. How the verticals hang on the wall is differnt but once you have the vertical hangers secured you can interchange most accessories. I can install shelf supports for any company on any one of the vertical hangers. So I used the Closetmaid clothes hamper in my Rubbermaid closet. Closetmaid shelf supports and shelves will fit on the Rubbermaid or Elfa vertical hangers and vice versa.
If money is not a concern then buy the Elfa, built like a tank will last forever and looks better than the others with the right accessories.
Rubbermaid is the least sturdy of the three but does the job. It is very easy to put up so if your not handy around the house then buy this one. You also can easily make changes to how you want the shelves organized much more so that the other two. If you want 16 inch shelves then look at their garage organizers, the system is the same.
I like Closetmaid but it does require more work to put up since you have to do all the cuttings. It is much sturdier than Rubbermaid since it is meant to be permanent once you put it in. Shelves snap in place which took some effort and would be difficult to remove. Rubbermaid has a simple slide to lock shelves in so you can makes changes easily but then again you give up some sturdiness.
Update 12/12/2011
After having used all three systems for almost three years I can say all of them hold up well. I haven't had any problems so my original feeling that Rubbermaid tend to be flimsy is still not a problem. I don't think you can go wrong with Rubbermaid and it is very easy to put up and being adjustable gives you room to customize the way you want it. Having parts left over is more of a mental problem because the cost of the kit is still probably cheaper than buying each part by itself even with the left over parts or you can try using all of it. Also as I said before you can use Closetmaid accessories with Rubbermaid and although I like my Closetmaid clothes hamper it did fall apart which was replaced by Lowe's at no cost.
I recently did my daughters closet using Rubbermaid but these were not adjustable. You buy what you need and cut to fit (Home Depot). These being not adjustable felt much sturdier. I did find putting in the shelves to be easier than Closetmaid. Closetmaid shelves snap in and are very tight. The Rubbermaid ones were just easier in that it has a slide that locks the shelves in place but Rubbermaid is more expensive than Closetmaid so you pay for this one feature.
My next project was using Rubbermaid. I liked the idea it was adjustable. It was very easy to install. I bought the delux 8 feet kit. One problem is you will sometimes have left over parts and in my case I also had to buy one extra part since the way I wanted it was a little different that what options you had with their kit. After installing it I found I just didn't need to change it, so the adjustability probaly was not a plus for me but some people may want to make changes after using it for awhile. Biggest negative which really isn't a negative is that it is flimsy compared to the Elfa which is like a tank. That is because it is adjustable but it is sturdy enough. I have no problems with that. Another possible negative is it only comes with 12 inch shelves for closets. If you really need something bigger you can go into their garage sections which has 16 inches shelves.
My last project was Closetmaid. I used Closetmaid for my wife's closet since she wanted 16 inch shelves and I didn't feel it needed to be adjustable. Now if you don't want to be doing your own cutting which can be a chore without the right tools then go with Rubbermaid. But I have the right tools so cutting was not a problem. I bought mine at Lowe's. If you have all your measurements you can do the cutting their. They have a bolt cutter that cuts right through it. I did all my cutting at home since I have bolt cutters and metal saws. I like Closetmaid since it was sturdier than Rubbermaid and I just buy what I need. It also has a nice selection of accessories from wire drawers to shoe organizers. What I really liked is their clothes hamper. It pulls out on a slide then pushes in after you throw your dirty clothes in.
Now the surprise is the vertical hangers for all three companies all have the same slot design. How the verticals hang on the wall is differnt but once you have the vertical hangers secured you can interchange most accessories. I can install shelf supports for any company on any one of the vertical hangers. So I used the Closetmaid clothes hamper in my Rubbermaid closet. Closetmaid shelf supports and shelves will fit on the Rubbermaid or Elfa vertical hangers and vice versa.
If money is not a concern then buy the Elfa, built like a tank will last forever and looks better than the others with the right accessories.
Rubbermaid is the least sturdy of the three but does the job. It is very easy to put up so if your not handy around the house then buy this one. You also can easily make changes to how you want the shelves organized much more so that the other two. If you want 16 inch shelves then look at their garage organizers, the system is the same.
I like Closetmaid but it does require more work to put up since you have to do all the cuttings. It is much sturdier than Rubbermaid since it is meant to be permanent once you put it in. Shelves snap in place which took some effort and would be difficult to remove. Rubbermaid has a simple slide to lock shelves in so you can makes changes easily but then again you give up some sturdiness.
Update 12/12/2011
After having used all three systems for almost three years I can say all of them hold up well. I haven't had any problems so my original feeling that Rubbermaid tend to be flimsy is still not a problem. I don't think you can go wrong with Rubbermaid and it is very easy to put up and being adjustable gives you room to customize the way you want it. Having parts left over is more of a mental problem because the cost of the kit is still probably cheaper than buying each part by itself even with the left over parts or you can try using all of it. Also as I said before you can use Closetmaid accessories with Rubbermaid and although I like my Closetmaid clothes hamper it did fall apart which was replaced by Lowe's at no cost.
I recently did my daughters closet using Rubbermaid but these were not adjustable. You buy what you need and cut to fit (Home Depot). These being not adjustable felt much sturdier. I did find putting in the shelves to be easier than Closetmaid. Closetmaid shelves snap in and are very tight. The Rubbermaid ones were just easier in that it has a slide that locks the shelves in place but Rubbermaid is more expensive than Closetmaid so you pay for this one feature.
Product Description
Organize your closet exactly the way you want with the Rubbermaid 3H89 Titanium Configurations Four to Eight Foot Deluxe Custom Closet Kit. This system can be customized, with no cutting required, to fit closet walls from four to eight feet long. The included shelves and hang rods are adjustable for up to 10 feet of hang space and 22 feet of stacking space. With eight more feet of shelf space than the Four to Eight Foot Classic Custom Closet Kit, the Deluxe is the perfect system for storing folded sweaters, blankets, and other bulky items. Flexible features make it quick and easy to reconfigure your closet. And because all the pieces in the kit are constructed with a nickel-and-chrome-colored satin epoxy finish, they will protect and store your clothes and other valuables for years to come..caption {font-family: Verdana, Helvetica neue, Arial, serif;font-size: 10px;font-weight: bold;font-style: italic;}ul.indent {list-style: inside disc;text-indent: 20px;}table.callout {font-family: Verdana, Helvetica, Arial, serif;margin: 10px;width: 250;}td.callout3-c26 {height: 100 percent;background: url('http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/th/content_26/Q1_2009/c26-callout3.png') repeat-y;border-left: 0px solid #999999;border-right: 1px solid #999999;padding: 10px;width: 250px;}ul.callout {list-style: inside disc;text-indent: -12px;font-size: 12px;line-height: 1.5em;}h5.callout {text-align: center;}img.withlink {border:1px black solid;}a.nodecoration {text-decoration: none}The 3H89 ConfigurationsDeluxe Custom Closet Kit offers:Shelves, expandable single- and double-hang rodsThe ability to fit any closet from 4 to 8 feet wideEasy installation with all necessary hardware includedA titanium-color finish that won't snag or rustThe telescoping rods and expanding shelves make reconfiguring your closet quick and simple. View larger. Click here to view some of the many ways that the 3H89 can be setup.Everything You Need in One BoxThe Deluxe Custom Closet Kit includes everything you need in one box to create a customized closet, allowing you to keep your home neat and organized. This kit includes four telescoping clothes rods, nine adjustable shelves, and all the hardware you need for quick and easy installation. The closet's track and upright system provides strength and versatility: the tracks make installation fast, and the uprights make it easy to reconfigure your closet at any time. The components have a clean, shiny look with a nickel-and-chrome-colored satin epoxy finish that will allow for years of maintenance-free durability, and the clothes rods provide free sliding with no wires to get in the way of your hangers.Maximize Your Storage SpaceThe Deluxe Custom Closet Kit is designed to help you make the most of your storage space. It is designed to fit closet spaces between four and eight feet long, up to 22 feet tall. With this kit you can create a double-hang section for shirts, skirts, and folded pants and create a long-hang section for dresses and suits. Store boxes, out-of-season items, and blankets on your top shelf, and use the lower shelves to store shoes and folded sweaters. Whatever your storage needs, the Deluxe Custom Closet Kit can be customized to do the job.Quick, Easy InstallationThe Deluxe Custom Closet Kit can be installed a few easy steps, with no cutting required. Simply mount the hang rails and adjust the shelves and telescoping rods--in a matter of minutes you will have a closet customized to your needs.About RubbermaidFor more than 70 years, Rubbermaid has committed to creating durable, innovative products that help simplify life and make living and work spaces more comfortable and attractive. From its original line of simple housewares, Rubbermaid has expanded to become a major designer of a wide array of products ranging from home and garden to seasonal and commercial products. Recognized as a "Brand of the Century" by the Brand Marketing magazine, Rubbermaid prides itself on being a name synonymous with excellent quality housewares.What's in the BoxTwo 48.25-inch shelves; seven 26.25-inch shelves; five 47.5-inch uprights; two 25-inch uprights; 19 brackets; two 48-inch hang rails; four 22-inch rail covers; nine rod hangers; and one each 48-inch inner clothes rod, 48-inch outer clothes rod, 26-inch inner clothes rod, and 26-inch outer clothes rod. All hardware included..matrix {font-family: Verdana, Helvetica neue, Arial, serif;font-size: 10px;}.matrix_feature {font-family: Verdana, Helvetica neue, Arial, serif;font-size: 9px;}.matrix_header {font-family: Verdana, Helvetica neue, Arial, serif;font-size: 12px;font-weight: bold;}Find the Rubbermaid Configurations Closet System That is Right for YouFor 3-6 Ft. ClosetsFor 4-8 Ft. ClosetsStarter"Good"WhiteTwo 36.25-inch shelves, one 26.25-inch shelf, 36-inch clothes rod, and 26-inch clothes rod.Classic"Better"WhiteTitaniumWhiteTitaniumTwo 36.25-inch shelves, three 26.25-inch shelves, 36-inch clothes rod, and 26-inch clothes rod.Two 48.25-inch shelves, three 26.25-inch shelves, 48-inch clothes rod, and 26-inch clothes rod.Deluxe"Best"WhiteTitaniumWhiteTitaniumTwo 36.25-inch shelves, six 26.25-inch shelves, 36-inch clothes rod, and 26-inch clothes rod.Two 48.25-inch shelves, seven 26.25-inch shelves, 48-inch clothes rod, and 26-inch clothes rod.
Features
- Custom closet storage kit for closets 4 to 8 feet
- Expandable and adjustable shelves for unsurpassed versatility
- 10 feet of hang space and 22 feet of shelving
- Satin nickel and chrome finish won't rust, chip, or crack
- Includes rack and all necessary hardware; lifetime warranty
No comments:
Post a Comment